A nurse on an acute mental health unit is caring for a group of clients. For which of the following clients is seclusion contraindicated?

Choice A rationale:

Repression: This statement suggests that the client is unconsciously blocking out memories of the tragedy as a way to cope with the anxiety. While repression can be a defense mechanism, it's not considered an adaptive use of sublimation.

Sublimation involves channeling anxiety into a productive or socially acceptable activity.

Denial of anxiety: The client's denial of anxiety, despite outward signs of distress, indicates a lack of awareness or acceptance of their emotional state. This can hinder effective coping and processing of the trauma.

Potential for delayed or prolonged distress: Repressed memories can resurface later, often in unexpected or disruptive ways, potentially leading to prolonged or intensified distress.

Choice B rationale:

Hopelessness and helplessness: The client's statement reflects a sense of defeat and a belief that they are incapable of overcoming the trauma. This can lead to feelings of despair, isolation, and withdrawal.

Lack of adaptive coping mechanisms: The client's inability to envision a future beyond the tragedy suggests a lack of healthy coping strategies to manage their anxiety and move forward.

Risk of prolonged distress and potential for depression: Persistent feelings of hopelessness and helplessness can increase the risk of developing depression or other mental health conditions.

Choice C rationale:

Denial of anxiety and potential lack of insight: The client's denial of anxiety, despite the nurse's observation, suggests a lack of awareness or acceptance of their emotional state. This can impede effective coping and processing of the trauma.

Potential resistance to support: The client's defensiveness may make it challenging for them to receive support or engage in therapeutic interventions.

Risk of delayed or unmanaged distress: If the client continues to deny their anxiety, they may not seek appropriate help, potentially leading to prolonged or intensified distress.

Choice D rationale:

Sublimation: This statement demonstrates the client's ability to channel their anxiety into a constructive and healthy outlet. Physical activity can provide a release for pent-up emotions, reduce stress, and improve overall well-being.

Adaptive coping mechanism: The client's choice to engage in physical activity as a way to manage their emotions indicates a positive coping strategy that can promote resilience and recovery.

Potential for improved mental and physical health: Regular exercise has numerous benefits for both mental and physical health, which can support the client's overall well-being and recovery process.

Rationale for Choice A:

While it is important to address the client's behavior, simply explaining that it was unacceptable is unlikely to be effective in this situation. Clients with antisocial personality disorder often have difficulty understanding and accepting responsibility for their actions. They may lack empathy for others and may not see their behavior as problematic. Confronting the client about their behavior too early in the therapeutic relationship could lead to defensiveness, hostility, or even aggression. It is important to first establish a rapport with the client and build a foundation of trust before addressing difficult topics.

Rationale for Choice B:

Setting behavioral limits is an important aspect of treatment for clients with antisocial personality disorder. However, it is not the first priority in this situation. Before setting limits, the nurse needs to establish a relationship with the client and assess their individual needs and level of functioning. Attempting to set limits without first establishing a rapport could lead to power struggles and further resistance from the client.

Rationale for Choice C:

Exploring the truth of the client's statements may be necessary at some point in the treatment process. However, it is not the first priority in this situation. The nurse's initial focus should be on establishing a relationship with the client and assessing their immediate needs. Focusing on the accuracy of the client's statements too early in the therapeutic process could derail the development of a trusting relationship.

Rationale for Choice D:

Establishing a client relationship is the first and most important step in the treatment of any client, but it is especially crucial for clients with antisocial personality disorder. These clients often have difficulty trusting others and forming close relationships. By establishing a rapport with the client, the nurse can begin to build trust and create a safe and supportive environment. This foundation is essential for any further therapeutic interventions to be successful.