A nurse is caring for a client who has schizophrenia.
Which of the following statements by the client demonstrates concrete thinking?

The rationale for Choice A:

Limiting time for rituals to 30 minutes each day may not be effective and could potentially increase anxiety. Individuals with OCD often feel a strong compulsion to perform their rituals, and abruptly restricting their ability to do so can heighten distress and lead to increased attempts to engage in the rituals, even in a covert manner. This can create a cycle of anxiety and frustration.

Gradual exposure and response prevention (ERP) therapy is a more effective approach to reducing ritualistic behaviors. It involves gradually exposing the individual to anxiety-provoking stimuli while helping them to resist engaging in their compulsions. This process is done in a controlled and supportive environment, to help the individual learn to manage their anxiety and reduce their reliance on rituals.

Rationale for Choice B:

Providing a stimulating environment is not generally recommended for individuals with OCD. Excessive stimulation can exacerbate anxiety and trigger compulsive behaviors. A calmer and more structured environment is often more beneficial.

Individuals with OCD often thrive in environments that provide predictability and a sense of control. A structured schedule can help to reduce uncertainty and create a sense of order, which can in turn help to reduce anxiety and the urge to engage in compulsive behaviors. Rationale for Choice C:

Negative reinforcement is not an appropriate or effective intervention for OCD. It involves punishing or removing a desired stimulus in response to a behavior, with the aim of decreasing the likelihood of that behavior occurring again. However, this approach can be counterproductive in OCD, as it can increase anxiety and make the individual more likely to engage in their rituals in order to avoid the negative consequences.

Positive reinforcement, such as praise and encouragement, is more effective in promoting desired behaviors. This approach focuses on rewarding the individual for making progress in reducing their ritualistic behaviors, which can help to increase motivation and create a more positive and supportive environment for change.

Rationale for Choice D:

Providing a structured schedule of activities can be a very effective intervention for OCD. It can help to reduce anxiety, provide a sense of control, and minimize the time available for engaging in compulsive rituals.

A structured schedule can include a variety of activities, such as:

Mealtimes

Personal hygiene routines

Work or school activities

Leisure activities

Relaxation exercises

Social interactions

The schedule should be tailored to the individual's specific needs and preferences. It is important to ensure that the activities are enjoyable and meaningful to the individual, as this will increase their motivation to participate.

The nurse can work with the individual to develop a schedule that is realistic and achievable. The schedule should be reviewed and adjusted regularly as the individual makes progress.

Choice A:

While this response is well-intentioned, it may not be the most therapeutic in this situation. It could be perceived as dismissive of the client's feelings and concerns. Clients with schizophrenia often have difficulty trusting others, and this response could reinforce the client's belief that they are being held against their will.

It's important to acknowledge the client's feelings and concerns, rather than simply stating that the healthcare team is there to help.

Choice B:

This response is the most therapeutic because it uses the technique of reflection. Reflection involves echoing back the client's feelings or thoughts, which can help them feel heard and understood. It can also encourage the client to elaborate on their concerns.

By reflecting the client's statement, the nurse validates their feelings and opens the door for further communication.

Choice C:

This response could be perceived as confrontational or challenging, which could further escalate the client's anxiety. It's generally more helpful to start with a more open-ended question or reflection.

Asking "why" questions can sometimes make people feel defensive or put on the spot.

Choice D:

While relaxation techniques can be helpful for some clients, this response is not appropriate in this situation. It minimizes the client's concerns and does not address their underlying feelings of fear and anxiety.

It's important to validate the client's feelings before suggesting coping strategies.